Issue No. 329

8 - 14February 2001

More documents confirm importation of potentially BSE-contaminated animal feed in 1980s

Authorities warned of BSE risk in 1990

by Franco Aloisio

Documents obtained by The Malta Business Weekly confirm without doubt that Malta used to import animal feed which had a high-risk of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy contamination (BSE) commonly known as Mad Cow.
This information, coupled with the revelations made by the UK Sunday Times this week, confirms that the fatal animal meal was being fed to local herds.
According to the UK Report of the BSE Inquiry, published last year, Malta had been importing ruminant-based meat and bone meal from the UK in the 1980s. These feeds were potentially BSE-contaminated.
Volume 3, chapter 6 of the BSE Inquiry report (entitled “Notification of the ruminant deed ban to other countries”) states that the then British Chief Veterinary Officer in the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAFF), Keith C. Meldrum, had written to the veterinary officers of several countries, including Malta, way back in 14 February 1990.
These countries were informed that they had been importing potentially BSE-infected meal.
This letter was highly influential in forcing the local authorities to ban the import of such products starting that same year. The fact that the importation of potentially BSE-infected meal was banned in 1990 was confirmed by government vet Dr Lino Vella on Monday in a local newspaper.
Another document – a paper published in Spring 2000 by the Optimal Wellness Centre – said that during the 1980s thousands of tons of meat and bone meal (MBM) were exported to cattle farms in BSE-free countries such as Malta.
Organic researcher Mark Purdley, author of the paper “Animal Pharm” said: “Not surprisingly, only a handful of folk had insight into the unsavoury world of MBM rendering business. But for anyone who had scratched the mere surface of the global distribution of British MBM products, it became strikingly obvious that the very mainstay of the official hypothesis was radically flawed.
“For instance, during the 1980s thousands of tons of this very same incriminated MBM was exported to cattle farms in BSE-free countries such as the Middle East, Malta and South Africa,” he said.
Dr Meldrum had written: “....I am writing to you on a personal basis to ensure that you are aware of all the developments in relation to BSE, including its likely cause.”
In his letter, sent also to the Maltese Veterinary Officer, the former Chief Veterinary Officer of the UK Dr Meldrum said he was writing mainly because of the trading links between the UK and Malta in either live animals or their products.
He wrote that BSE is a novel neurological disorder of cattle, first identified in Great Britain in November 1986. It is one of a group of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, which includes scrapie in sheep and Creutzfeldt Jakob Disease (cJD) in humans.
In his 1990 letter to Malta, Dr Meldrum said that epidemiological investigations have concluded that cattle were most probably exposed to the agent of scrapie via commercial cattle feedstuffs which contained meat and bone meal derived from sheep.
“A number of factors have been identified which, in combination, precipitated the emergence of the disease in 1986 following an increase in the exposure of animals to the causal agent in 1981 or 1982. In the light of this, the use in ruminant feedstuffs of protein material derived from ruminant animals has been prohibited in the UK since July 1988,” he said.
Malta stopped imports to feed meat and bone meal for cattle in 1990. However in an another letter sent in 1990, Dr Meldrum said several nations have not fully appreciated the possible hazards from British meat and bone meal, “since only a few nations have either banned our imports or the more general feeding of ruminant material”.
The latest issue of the Sunday Times of London quoted Whitehall documents revealing that as many as 70 countries, including Malta, received more than 200,000 tons of protein potentially contaminated with BSE between 1988 and 1996.
This protein for animal feed was exported by Britain’s main producer of potentially contaminated MBM – Prosper de Mulder, Britain’s largest rendering company, which processes by-products such as offal and carcases unfit for human consumption. The company is reported to have a turnover of £120m a year.

  © Standard Publications Limited 1999