Issue No. 338

12 - 18 April 2001

2000 witnesses significant widening of the current account deficit

The Central Bank of Malta last week published its Annual Report for the year 2000. The following is an analysis of economic and financial developments in Malta and abroad, and a review of the bank’s policies, operations and activities.

In its review of domestic economic developments, the Report estimates that the economy grew by around four per cent during 2000. Export-oriented manufacturing, particularly in the electronics sub-sector, contributed strongly to GDP growth, compensating for a modest performance in the tourist industry and in the locally oriented manufacturing and services sectors.
After having remained subdued during the previous four years, investment grew strongly in 2000. The rate of job creation also accelerated, particularly in the directly productive sectors. As a result, unemployment fell to 4.5 per cent, but underlying inflation continued to decline; however, at around one per cent, it remained somewhat higher than imported inflation.
The Report then focuses on developments in the balance of payments, pointing out that the year 2000 witnessed a significant widening of the current account deficit. This was, however, largely attributable to a number of exogenous factors, including the hike in international oil prices, a substantial rise in imports of capital goods, and a surge in investment income outflows as foreign firms located in Malta recorded a large increase in profits.
Meanwhile, the surplus on the capital and financial account contracted in spite of these earnings having been reinvested in Malta. The main contributing factors were higher portfolio reinvested outflows and a lower level of inward direct investment compared to 1999 when inflows were boosted by the sale of Mid-Med Bank to HSBC Group.
Commenting on the movements of the Maltese lira, the Report observes that the currency generally appreciated against the euro and weakened against the US dollar through most of the year, reflecting the persistent depreciation of the euro against the US currency. Against sterling, meanwhile, the Maltese lira was relatively stable.
Turning to fiscal developments the Report notes that the improvement in public finances during 2000 was greater than anticipated, with the fiscal deficit being provisionally estimated at Lm95 million, or six per cent of GDP. Furthermore, projections for 2001 show that fiscal consolidation should continue, and that the government’s objective of bringing the deficit down to 3-4 per cent of GDP by 2004 is within reach. This, the Report observes, should dampen pressures on prices and on the balance of payments.
With regard to monetary and financial developments the Report says that the annual growth rate of broad money was halved to around four per cent during 2000. This partly reflected a slower expansion in domestic credit and in the net foreign assets of the banking system. However, the slowdown in the growth of deposits also reflected the growing popularity of collective investment schemes and foreign portfolio investment, as well as a greater recourse to the capital market by the private sector to raise long-term finance.
Synthesising these developments, the Governor observes in his statement that the year 2000 was characterised by divergent trends in Malta’s internal and external accounts. On the one hand, the government’s macroeconomic stabilisation programme produced positive results and, in spite of the fiscal tightening and higher oil prices, a steady pace of economic activity was maintained. On the other hand, developments in the balance of payments deserved close attention as they clouded the economy’s medium term prospects, particularly as capital is increasingly mobile and sensitive to domestic economic conditions.
Concerns regarding the balance of payments invariably lead to questions about the exchange rate which is a key issue for the Central Bank as the main operational objective of its monetary policy is to maintain the exchange rate peg in order to achieve its ultimate goal of price stability.
In this regard, the Governor rules out both the adoption of a flexible exchange rate regime, because the associated fluctuations and uncertainty would be detrimental to a small and open economy such as Malta’s, and devaluation, because this presupposes that sufficient slack exists in the economy to meet an eventual increase in export demand, and that costs – particularly wages – would not rise in response to higher inflation. Experience has shown that in a local context the competitive advantage gained by devaluation tends to be short lived. It would, moreover, undermine the country’s reputation for exchange rate stability with existing and potential investors.
A more lasting solution to the balance of payments imbalance, the Governor concludes, does not therefore lie exclusively in macroeconomic adjustment, but also in microeconomic reforms aimed at maximising efficiency in the use of resources. For this to happen, it is essential that a more investment-friendly business climate be fostered and that prices be allowed to fully reflect the production costs of goods and services, and that the resources employed be rewarded accordingly
In this regard the Governor identifies a number of areas susceptible to the achievement of efficiency gains. These include: the labour market, where wages should reflect productivity more closely and a culture of safeguarding jobs through efficient work practices should be promoted; the educational system, which should increasingly provide the skills most in demand in a modern economy; the public sector, where the excessive absorption of human resources imposes a tax burden on other sectors; the financial markets, where uncertainty about Malta’s commitment to EU membership is adversely affecting inflows of foreign direct investment the real estate market, where rent controls have contributed to artificially inflate prices; the provision of public goods and services by the State free of charge; subsidies to public enterprises; the payment of contributions from the receipt of benefits; and monopolistic practices in the markets for goods and services.
The Governor stresses that with the economy’s competitiveness increasingly under threat, the restructuring process currently underway needs to be extended across a broader front. For this purpose he calls for a common effort by all interested parties to devise ways: to relate the provision of welfare payments and free medical, social and tertiary education services more closely to needs, to create a smaller, but more professional and accountable public service, and to introduce greater competition into monopoly situations, particularly in key economic sectors.
Turning to the short-term prospects for the Maltese economy, the Governor quotes Central Bank forecasts which suggest that the growth rate should rise to four-4.5 per cent in 2001, while inflation should moderate to 1.5-2 per cent. Growth in domestic demand should be contained, as the fiscal deficit is to be reined in further.
On the other hand, the deficit in the external account is expected to persist, although should narrow as the exceptional factors observed in 2000 are unlikely to be repeated, while the export sector should record an improved performance.

The bank’s operations
and activities
In the light of the need to adapt to the rapidly changing environment, the bank reviewed its core functions and objectives during 2000. Thus, its revised Mission Statement, which is reproduced in the Report, emphasises price stability as the primary objective of monetary policy.
The Bank’s Monetary Policy Council left interest rates unchanged throughout the year. Consequently the central intervention rate and the discount rate remained at 4.75 per cent. Meanwhile the interest rate liberalisation process was completed in April when the bank removed the last restriction on bank lending rates.
The bank’s net profits during 2000 amounted to Lm26 million, compared with Lm23 million in 1999.
The Annual Report will be available on the website of the Central Bank of Malta at www.centralbankmalta.com.

  © Standard Publications Limited 1999