Issue No. 343

17 - 23 May 2001

Farmers’ survival depends on produce being subsidised

by Ivan Brincat

The Maltese government is still finalising its position paper vis-à-vis the Common Agricultural Policy and this chapter will not be opened under the Swedish presidency.
Foreign affairs minister Joe Borg told The Malta Business Weekly there was no urgency to complete the position paper since the European Union has stated that agriculture will be one of the last chapters to be closed during negotiations with candidate countries.
He said work on the chapter was still under way as the government was going into a lot of detail to come up with a package for the agriculture industry.
“It is better for us to take our time and come up with a good position paper,” Dr Borg told The Malta Business Weekly.
Originally, the position paper on agriculture had to be completed very early in the year and the government had set January as a target date.
It is now expected that the agricultural chapter will be opened under the Belgian presidency of the EU which begins on 1 July.
The size of the chapter (it is more than half of the EU’s acquis) as well as some of the impact assessment reports the government has on the sector are the main causes of the delay.
Earlier this year, the chairman of the core negotiating group Richard Cachia Caruana had said the government would be asking for a special package for Malta since it presented a special case due to its size.
Senior government sources told The Malta Business Weekly that economies of scale would always be detrimental to Maltese farmers whatever they do.
A decision therefore had to be taken to safeguard the rural environment and this would automatically lead to farmers having to be subsidised for their produce since the EU products would come to Malta cheaper.
In fact Mr Cachia Caruana had stated that Maltese farming was equivalent to 2.5 per cent of the GDP and contributed to less than two per cent of employment. However, he said farming was important and he had asked who would maintain terraced fields.
“The Maltese government will thus be asking for a special package which is being prepared. While respecting the Common Agriculture Policy, the package being proposed will take into consideration the realities that exist,” Mr Cachia Caruana said.
A study commissioned by the government was carried out by CIHEAM and although this provided a lot of food for thought, sources said operators in the field knew about the problems the sector would face. “The study just identified what we had already known but it pinpoints various sectors and shows that Malta might not be competitive in areas such as poultry, pork and the production of particular vegetables among others.
Producers in the poultry and pork sector depend on total protection therefore they will be negatively affected. Moreover the EU directives make it extremely hard for these sectors to expand and reach the necessary economies of scale.
Other products like vegetables, tomatoes, wine and milk can be sustained with heavy investment. However, the focus will have to be on products with added value, the sources said.
Other studies, the sources added, are in the pipeline and the last one, which is being finalised, provides options to the dismantling of levies.

  © Standard Publications Limited 1999