Issue No. 345

31 May - 6 June 2001

Possible arrangement on
free movement of capital

by Ivan Brincat

The European Commission has hinted at the possibility of Malta obtaining a transition period vis-à-vis the free movement of capital chapter.
The head of the European Commission’s Malta team Arhi Palosuo said that Cyprus had been granted a five-year transition period for the purchase of secondary residences by foreigners. “I am not saying that Malta should copy this position but to show what is happening with other candidate countries,” he said.
Malta has asked for a permanent derogation on the purchase of a secondary residence by foreigners and the joint position of the EU has so far been negative with the EU requesting more information.
Finance minister John Dalli has explained that steps had been taken recently so that the extra taxation on foreigners purchasing property in Malta was totally removed and now the same level of tax applies for Malta.
“There is little difficulty for foreigners to purchase one property in Malta. Our position, because of our size, makes the situation difficult and we need the tools to control any possible problems that might arise,” Mr Dalli said.
On the other hand, Mr Palosuo maintained the position that any decision on a permanent derogation will have to be taken by all member states in unanimity.
“It is still to early to state whether there is the political will to accept a derogation and how deep this will go. But it is very difficult to derogate on some basic principles of the internal market such as free movement of persons,” he said.
Turning to the free movement of capital chapter, Mr Palosuo said the chances for a permanent derogation were limited but the European Union was keeping an open mind. “We are working on a solution and there are some possibilities.”Last week, The Malta Business Weekly published parts of the draft European Union’s Common position. In their position, the EU said it has not accepted requests made by Malta for a permanent derogation vis-à-vis the acquisition of real estate by foreigners as a secondary residence. It has asked Malta to provide additional information to justify its requests.
Mr Palosuo acknowledges that property ownership is a politically sensitive issue and has to be looked into. “For example we have had a complicated discussion regarding the purchase of agricultural land. Malta does not have such a problem. Fear existed in some candidate countries and they asked for an 18-year transition period and in some cases 10 years. We are proposing a seven-year transition period to allow the candidate countries to carry out the necessary reform. Nationalist MP Michael Frendo raised the issue of the purchase of property during the joint parliamentary committee. Dr Frendo said that Malta had a law which allowed non-residents to purchase property and measures had been taken to encourage foreigners to purchase property. “But land in Malta is at a premium and it is important that government keeps some form of power. Whether by a derogation or a special arrangement, the EU should give due recognition for Malta on this subject and creatively try to find ways either for a particular period of time or periodically reviewed.”

  © Standard Publications Limited 1999